SOLUTIONSTracker

Business as Usual or real solutions?
Find out here:

  • Barack Obama

    Climate superstar or just another coal industry chum?

John McCain

I will clean up the planet. I will make global warming a priority.

That was McCain speaking before the New Hampshire primary. The anti-McCain pundits of the right ate it up like hot fudge. Fodder for their hatred. McCain = Al Gore's ideological twin.

Um, no.

When McCain invokes climate rhetoric it's political opportunism. Period. Like in New Hampshire -- a state filled with Independents who rank global warming high on their list of concerns.

Unfortunate truth (lost on his GOP enemies): John McCain is not a major champion of climate change solutions.

Not anymore. Not even close. The times they have changed. And so, apparently, has McCain.

Register or login to subscribe to updates from solve climate

Bottom Line Roundup

  • McCain's been silent on the fight over new coal plants. He has advocated cleaner coal at times. Courtesy of Grist's interview with McCain:

    Grist: What role do you think coal should play in America's energy future?

    McCain: I'd like to see coal gasification, and I would subsidize R&D in that effort. I'm all for government funding basic R&D, by the way. I really believe that we're going to have to use a kind of a coal [technology] that does not emit the greenhouse gases that present-day coal-fired utility plants do.

  • Doesn't appear to be a priority. Although in 2005, he co-sponsored the EFFECTER Act (Efficient Energy Through Certified Technologies and Electricity Reliability). It would have provided tax incentives for energy-efficient offices, homes, and appliances and other energy-efficiency measures.

  • McCain co-sponsored the first mandatory cap-and-trade bill in the US Senate in 2003, the Lieberman-McCain Climate Stewardship Act. It was a worthy gesture for its time. But it did not pass the Senate.

    He vocally opposed the 2007 watered-down version of the bill, Lieberman-Warner, for not piling on the nuclear hand-outs.

    He is strongly opposed to a carbon tax. And, in an odd show of cap-and-trade jujitsu, he recently dared to suggest that the climate bill he supported is not a mandatory cap on emissions.

  • In 2002, McCain sponsored a bill in the US Senate that would have raised auto efficiency standards to 36 mpg by 2016. Though as Grist notes, McCain was a no-show for the vote on the 2007 energy bill that contained a provision to raise fuel economy for cars and trucks to 35 miles per gallon by 2020.

    McCain came out in favor of California's right to pass its own tailpipe emissions law.

  • McCain has not specifically mentioned a green job corps by name, nor has he endorsed any policy specifics. But while in Michigan -- and elsewhere on the campaign trail -- he has pledged a beefed up job-training system, one oriented toward green technology.

  • In 2005, McCain voted against a renewable portfolio standard that would have required the U.S. to get 10 percent of its electricity from renewable sources by 2020.

    And in both Dec 2007 and Feb 2008, he missed crucial votes that prevented clean energy packages from passing the Senate floor.

    Should have predicted it. Here's the response McCain gave to Grist back in October '07 on subsidies for green tech:

    I'm not one who believes that we need to subsidize things. The wind industry is doing fine, the solar industry is doing fine. In the '70s, we gave too many subsidies and too much help, and we had substandard products sold to the American people, which then made them disenchanted with solar for a long time.

  • McCain has been vocal in the past about the US needing to be a global leader in slashing emissions. But. His party line smacks of Bush: Yes to the Kyoto treaty if -- and only if -- it includes China and India. Chindia, the favorite whipping boy of the GOP. The perennial excuse for inaction.

Related Posts